97 Jetta Keys dont match

Hey welcome to the site. sounds like a nice car. so when you have time can you post some pics of your car? as far as your question goes tho i have never herd of having 2 keys. so can't help you out there. sorry. When i bought my car it came with 2 keys but one was a master key and the other was just a spare that couldn't get into personal stuff like opening the trunk or glove box

Probably not. Try calling a couple import shops on your phone book and see if they can work on your car. Don't forget to ask them whats your estimate for the car so you can pick which spot you really want to take your car too.